Our panelists on the latest and greatest celebrity looks

Taylor Swift in a scarlet stage look in Dallas, Texas

Eva Wiseman, columnist at The Observer
Words and songs aren't enough. Now Taylor Swift is actually DRESSING like a broken heart. Applause. Applause.

Laura Silver, staff writer at Never Underdressed
Hey Taylor, Liza Minnelli wants her look back. Of course, I’d never knock the grand dame of OTT, nor the princess of pop-country, but maybe the latter should leave the elbow-length gloves and neat bows to the 'establishment' (sorry Liza) and send this showtime-glamour look into a youthful spin with some wild hair or a fistful of gothy rings. 

Mandi Lennard, brand consultant and founder of Mandi's Basement
Uh oh, what is this Marilyn Monroe meets X-factor TV presenter monstrosity?  Please Taylor, stop with trying to dress like a Hollywood starlet and get down with the kids.  You're the only person below the age of 25 who doesn't seem to use hair product. You need to muss up that mane, and break free in a cheeky print strapless dress by Ashley Williams. Or if you do insist on this full-length red carpet thing, then please please have a consultation with Sadie Williams, who presented her stiff silhouette lurex gowns at the Central Saint Martins MA show last London Fashion Week. They're the way to go!

(left to right: Eva Wiseman, Laura Silver, Mandi Lennard)