Our panelists on the latest and greatest celebrity looks

Lily Collins wearing a Versace dress and Casadei heels on a promotional tour for The Mortal Instruments: City Of Bones in New York yesterday 

Lynn Enright, staff writer at Never Underdressed
I love her eyebrows and lips but, while I admire how groomed she is, I find the overall look a tad too polished. With such a sleek Versace dress – that yellow fabric enveloping her tiny frame in an ultra-fashionable hug – I feel she could have gone more out-there with her hair, something messy and big, or her shoes, which are a lovely olive colour, but a little too neat for this ensemble to truly sing.

Dolly Alderton, TV producer and writer 
Lily's framed her perfect little porcelain doll face with strong brows and vampy, dark lipstick. Her bandaged canary yellow dress is bold yet simple and elegant, making the most of her slim frame. So far, so good. You might say – just another day in paradise. But then we head south to the shoes and it all goes a bit Pete Tong. She has jumped on the latest young-woman-wears-ironic-Chelsea-mother-at-a-Harrow-school-parents-evening trend and it doesn't work with the outfit. Heels need to be big to be heard under the volume of this loud dress.

Sunil Makan, picture editor at Never Underdressed
Just as I was starting to really j'adore Lily – I mean did you see those over-the-knee boots yesterday and she rocks a berry lip like no one else and has the most beautiful set of brows, ever – she opts for this beamer of a dress. I don't totally hate it but there's something sweetcorn-esque about it. The saving grace? The brows, the lips, the artfully arranged rings and olive heels.   

Left to right: Lynn Enright; Dolly Alderton; Sunil Makan)